Eggless Cupcake Challenge

I didn’t get a chance to blog yesterday, as I was working on a hmmm project I guess you’d say.  I have a friend who has some severe allergies, and many of them being food allergies. One of those is eggs. Eggs?!?!? Let me tell you something… I never in my life realized how many things have eggs or egg product in them!  She brought me this Egg Replacer powder and I basically looked at it like “What the heck do I do with this???”. I’m always up for a challenge though, and I have felt especially bad that she hasn’t even been able to eat any of the treats I have made. I even thought about making her a fruit basket but then I found out she’s allergic to just about all the fruits I use as well! So I started digging online and researching some egg substitutes and how to use the egg replacer powder. It was actually quite interesting. At first, I tried it with a simple cake mix (although the box says it doesn’t work well with it). I wanted to get an idea of what I was working with and wanted to make something easy for her to be able to make on her own if it actually worked. She isn’t a fan of the from scratch baking.  I mixed the powder with a little water and then added it to the mix in place of the eggs and stuck them in the oven. The cupcakes came out ok visually, a little lighter than usual and obviously flatter than usual since eggs are part of the leavening in the batter. However, they were the strangest consistency! They felt squishy, yet heavy.  Then when I went to taste one and break it apart, it was as if the whole thing fell to crumbs. They weren’t dry, dense crumbs, as corn bread would be.  They were more like moist, velvety crumbs but when you touched them and put them together, they’d turn to a dough. I was absolutely befuddled by this. I had never really felt something that consistency. The closest thing I can compare it to is the “Moon Sand” that’s out for the kids now, or kinetic sand. It was really interesting, but they tasted good!

Next, I wanted to try it in a scratch recipe.  I chose a lemon cupcake recipe since she isn’t allergic to lemons and it would give her a little flavor. I found the egg replacer worked a little better in this type of recipe, but I still had a problem with the rising and it being slightly crumbly. The taste, however, was still quite good. I decided to make some homemade vanilla buttercream and pipe them onto them and let her try them to see what she thought. She loved them! I was so excited for her. I’m still not done with this challenge though. I want to try to tweak the consistency. I read to try gelatin with the egg replacer so I want to try that. I also read to use soda as an egg substitute as well. So I have much more work to do and experimenting with this, but overall she was happy that I produced something edible without eggs that she could actually enjoy! I’ll take any suggestions if any of you have them though, especially regarding consistency.  It was an interesting challenge but I’m up for more research!


5 thoughts on “Eggless Cupcake Challenge

  1. mowglismom says:

    I have used Ener-G egg replacer with good results. But I only use it in from-scratch recipes that call for 1-2 eggs. I’ve found it works especially well for me when I make Nestle Toll House chocolate chip cookies or yeast rolls.

    That being said, I usually avoid trying to adapt recipes with eggs, and instead make vegan recipes (my son’s also allergic to milk). Post Punk Kitchen is one of my favorite sites for yummy egg-free baked goods.

    If your friend can have cocoa, this is my favorite eggless chocolate cake recipe. It makes a TON of cupcakes. Just fill the cups 1/2 full and bake for 20-25 minutes (check with a wooden toothpick). Friends and family are always amazed when I tell them this cake doesn’t have any eggs or milk in it. And, believe it or not, many of them actually prefer this cake to “traditional” chocolate cake.

    Happy baking! ~Christina


  2. adashofsweetcreations says:

    Thank you for that. I felt bad she could never eat anything I made. I’m glad there are so many options out there now for those with food allergies though! I found it interesting to work with the egg replacer and challenging to find something that looks and tastes good as well. I really appreciate that. If you find other yummy eggless recipes please let me know! Thanks!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s